21 April 2014

Sign-on statement: welcome 457 visa holders into the unions

Print Friendly

Gina Rinehart’s Enterprise Migration Agreement (EMA) for her Roy Hill project has sparked debate over the issue of “Aussie jobs” and 457 visas. This statement of union activists, anti-racists and others expresses concern over the anti-foreign worker sentiment, and argues unions should welcome temporary workers on 457 visas into the unions. Please read and consider signing on.

Welcome 457 visa holders into the unions: to fight for jobs we need to fight together

We the undersigned would like to express our concern over the anti-foreign worker sentiment from sections of the union movement to the announcement of the EMA (Enterprise Migration Agreement) that will allow Gina Rinehart to employ 1715 overseas workers (of a total workforce of 8000).

A campaign directed at overseas 457 workers is misdirected and detrimental to building our unions and the unity we need to face up to aggressive mining bosses and the challenge of job losses in manufacturing sector.

Thousands of jobs have been lost over the past few months. More than 3700 jobs went in the first five weeks of 2012—from banks, Qantas, Telstra, Heinz, Mortein and others.

These jobs were not lost because of foreign workers, but because of greedy employers who are only concerned with boosting company profits. It is big business, Australian bosses included, that are determined to cut wages and conditions, outsource to contractors, impose short time and push to casualise the workforce to exploit Australian workers and overseas workers alike.

On paper guest workers on 457 visas are meant to have the same pay and conditions as Australian workers, but if 457s are sacked, they have only 28 days to find another employer—or they must leave the country.

Recent reports that 250 Chinese workers on the Sino Iron project in the Pilbara are only getting $70,000 to $80,000 for jobs for which Australian workers would be paid about $150,000 is just the most recent example of how bosses will try to exploit 457 workers.

Without oversight and with the employer having the power over their visa and therefore to determine whether they stay or go, 457s remain vulnerable and open to exploitation.

The right to permanent residency has to be a central demand of the union movement to prevent any attempt to divide the workforce between local workers and 457 workers.

Enterprise Migration Agreements and the employment of 457 workers must be subject to union oversight and employment under a union-negotiated enterprise agreement.

The best way to fight Gina Rinehart and other bosses is to recruit the 457 workers into the unions, fight for their right to stay, and build a united union movement that is willing and able to fight for every job.

To ensure 457 visa workers are not exploited we demand that they have:

(i) the right to permanent residency;
(ii) the same rights and conditions as local workers on the job; and access to on-the-job training;
(iii) information provided in different languages, with translators are available on the job;
(iv) paid English classes on the job.

We reject all attempts to weaken our unions’ collective strength by dividing worker against worker.

Please email solidarity [at] solidarity.net.au to add your name

Dr Sarah Gregson, NTEU Branch President, University of New South Wales
Michael Thomson, President, University of Sydney NTEU Branch
Jim Casey, NSW Secretary, FBEU
Aran Mylvaganam, Victoria FSU Organiser
Ramesh Fernandez, RISE
Ben Convey, member of Victorian MEAA & ASU private sector
Katie George, CPSU
Chris Breen, Sensis, AMWU delegate (FoC) & AMWU Victorian State Councillor
Alex Loke, Sensis AMWU Delegate
Martin Raspin, Sensis AMWU Delegate
Katherine Morris, Sensis, AMWU
Jon Clarke , TWU National Eduction Coordinator (personal capacity)
Sam Salvidge (personal capacity)
Jasmine Ali, Victoria University, NTEU
David Glanz, RMIT branch, NTEU
Lucy Honan, St Albans, AEU
Melanie Lazarow, University of Melbourne NTEU
Professor Verity Burgmann, University of Melbourne, NTEU
Graeme Lechte, TAFE Victoria University, member AEU
Lachlan Marshall, Brunswick Secondary School, AEU
Jodi Sita, La Trobe University, NTEU member
Sean Redmond, Deakin Uni, NTEU member
Jonathon Sherlock, AEU (student member)
Chip Henriss, ASU member
Katharine Massam, NTEU
Shane Reside, Organiser Syd Uni Branch NTEU
Dr Tad Tietze, ASMOF member (personal capacity)
Dr Nick Riemer, NTEU member, University of Sydney
Jeff Rickertt, Together Member, Queensland
Marijke Hoving, NTEU member, University of Sydney
Clr Christine Donayre, Greens Councillor, Industrial Officer with the FBEU & member of the USU
Lorenzo White, organiser CFMEU (ACT)
Stephen Stefanac, Delegate, CPSU
Mark Goudkamp, NSW Teachers Federation Anti-Racism Policy Committee and Blacktown Teachers Association
Judy McVey CPSU member
Paul Young, CPSU Section Councilor DHS
Renea McCauley CPSU Section Councillor
Jo Ball, CPSU member
Elizabeth Humphrys, NTEU Member, University of Sydney Branch
Anne Picot, NTEU Member, University of Sydney Branch
Phil Griffiths, Lecturer, Political Economy, USQ and NTEU member (personal capacity)
Kevin Lin, NTEU University of Technology, Sydney
Ushter Abbasi, casual organiser, NUW NSW
Emma Torzillo, HSU member, NSW
Paddy Gibson, NTEU member, Jumbunna Indigenous House of Learning, UTS
Michael Swanton, Secretary, Association of Australian Workers
Hamish McPherson, Victorian Branch Councillor (Primary Sector), AEU
Jan Dobbs, CPSU member
Christina Ho, Senior Lecturer, Social Inquiry and NTEU member, UTS
Liam Brown, NUW Member, Victoria
James Goodman, Assoc. Prof., Academic VP NTEU, UTS Branch
Jeff Sparrow, author and editor, Overland
Adrian Davies, AEU member
Le Tam Tu, PhD student, CPCE, FASS, UTS
Anthea Vogl, NTEU UTS
Penny McCall Howard, USU member and MUA Research and Policy Coordinator – International issues (personal capacity)
Tim Hardman, BJ Ball (Boomerang Paper), AMWU Delegate
Mark Austin, Delegate, CPSU (BoM)
Timothy Hume, Delegate, CPSU (BoM)
Shaun Johnson, Delegate, CPSU (BoM)
Andrew Martin, AMWU WA
Peter Farago, NTEU Member 1972 – 2007
Neha Madhok, National Environment Officer, National Union of Students
Marisol Salinas, member ASU
LASNET (Latin American Solidarity Network)
Greg Platt CPSU Statistics Section Councillor (personal capacity)
RMIT University NTEU branch committee
Mel Slee, President, RMIT NTEU branch committee
Jordan Clarke, Melbourne Uni Refugee Action Collective
Aurelian Mondon, LaTrobe Uni NTEU
Cath Edwards, Melbourne Uni RAC
Tom Orsag CFMEU member
Kate Parks, refugee activist
Peter Carter, ANF member
Linda Hadley
Matthew Henderson, Bargaining Campaign Officer, Strategic Industrial Bargaining Team, NSW Nurses’ Association
Paul Daniele, Melbourne Anarchist Club, Anarcho-Syndicalist Federation Melbourne
Claire Parfitt, NTEU member, Sydney Uni
Peter Curtis, AEU sub-branch president
Josh Coy, ASU member
Julie Ross, NSW Teachers Federation councillor, Eastern Suburbs Teachers Association
Shane Hopkinson, NTEU member
Antony Loewenstein, independent journalist and author
Bill Dunn, NTEU member, University of Sydney
Professor Heather Goodall, NTEU member, UTS
Mike Beggs, NTEU member, University of Sydney
Avril Alba, NTEU member, University of Sydney
Tom Barnes, Lecturer in Political Economy, NTEU member, University of Sydney
Stuart Rosewarne, Lecturer in Political Economy, NTEU member, University of Sydney
Padraig Dorrigan, ASU
Damien Cahill, Vice President (Academic), NTEU, University of Sydney
Gillian Hewitson, NTEU member, University of Sydney
Robert Stainsby, CPSU member
Nikki Amai, Hazara Youth Perspectives Organisation Public Officer
John Tozer, member of the Builders Labourers’ Federation, Queensland
Melissa Brooks, Marrickville Councillor (Greens) and member of the ASU
Byrnn O’Brien, lawyer
Anita Creasey, NTEU Member, NUS West President
Duncan Wallace, Campus Refugee Rights Club Activist, Melb Uni
Dr Nour Dados, NTEU member, Faculty of Education and Social Work, University of Sydney
Raewyn Connell, NTEU, University of Sydney Branch
Sandra Rogers, NSW Teachers Federation Councillor, Teachers’ Association
Bruce Knobloch, personal capacity
Bill Keats, StandUp!
David Joseph, Member, Australian Education Union
Susan Price and Peter Boyle, national co-convenors of Socialist Alliance
Lyndal Butler, President, UTS Students Association
Jess Xu, Ethno-Cultural Officer, UTS Students Association

Article Tags

Related Posts


  1. Shane Reside, Organiser NTEU Syd Uni Branch

    Shane Reside, Organiser Syd Uni Branch NTEU

  2. Dr_Tad

    Dr Tad Tietze, ASMOF member (personal capacity)

    [An excellent initiative, sorry for not signing on sooner]

  3. JM

    This statement is a thinly veiled cover of support for the ALP government’s agreement with Gina Rinehart’s “Enterprise Migration” demands.

    Implicit in it is future support for ANY company that wishes to use the 457 visa scheme to fill the labor force with ANY NUMBER of foreign workers. Take the newly opening giant Indian or Chinese mines in Queensland or the Pilbara as examples where it has been suggested, and in some places brought to fruition, that most of the workers would be immigrants. Under your method of thinking: why not, provided that they are in the union. If they are made permanent citizens, this would add to the problem by enlarging the number of workers seeking employment irrespective of the state of the economy because your “anti-racism” applies independent of the rate of unemployment among Australians, now or in the future.

    In support of your position you use the deceptive argument that unemployment isn’t created by immigration but is a problem caused by capitalism and leave it at that. Capitalism is the system under which workers struggle, not a planned economy. Their grandfathers found in the 1930′s Depression that the huge numbers of British migrants brought to Australia in the 1920′s made Australian unemployment in the Thirties among the highest in the World.

    The reality is that in a world where jobs are scarce immigration plays a critical role in determining the rate of unemployment, in the same way that outsourcing, overt or covert, does. Only middle class dilettantes would propose otherwise.

    The fact is that your proposal is a form of racism directed at Australian workers on behalf of Big Business.

    Maybe when the predominantly well placed middle class signers of this petition find themselves in a more precarious position will they take a different position. Australian workers generally have other viewpoints on the matter despite your calling them “racists”.

  4. James Supple


    Big business would love to distract local workers into thinking that migrants are the enemy, not the bosses and the government. The fact is anti-immigrant demands take the unions’ focus away from organising on the job against the boss to lobbying the government to cut immigration.

    It is not true that the level of jobs is fixed either–look at how the ETU in Victoria has organised on the job to win higher employment of apprentices. It is possible to fight the bosses and the government to force them to create jobs–instead of destroying them as they do all the time to boost profits.

    It is well established that immigration actually creates jobs. This is because it generates demand through more mouths to feed, need for more housing and so on. Look at the post-war boom in Australia: there was a high rate of immigration where the government actually paid for the passage of immigrants to Australia through the 1950s and the economy boomed.
    See here for evidence http://localhost/solidarity.net.au/457-visas-special/immigration-is-not-to-blame-for-cuts-to-jobs-and-wages/

    You are also wrong about the 1930s. The years of the Depression were a period of almost no immigration. From 1930-1934 net migration was negative (more people left than arrived) yet unemployment kept rising: from 21 per cent in mid-1930 to 32 per cent in mid-1932.

  5. keith dwyer

    Based on the principles of equity and fairness, all employees should receive equal pay and conditions for equal work. – kd

  6. Mark Goudkamp

    Here are a few more signatories:
    Sandra Rogers, NSW Teachers Federation Councillor, Teachers’ Association
    Bruce Knobloch, personal capacity
    Bill Keats, StandUp!


Who are Solidarity?

Solidarity is a socialist group with branches across Australia.
We are opposed to the madness of capitalism, which is plunging us into global recession and misery at the same time as wrecking the planet’s future. We are taking the first steps towards building an organisation that can help lead the fight for an alternative system based on mass democratic planning, in the interests of human need not profit. Read more about Solidarity here or check out details of our meetings and events here.

Contact Solidarity

Phone (02) 9211 2600
Email solidarity[at]solidarity.net.au
Post PO Box 375 Strawberry Hills NSW Australia 2012
Or use the contact page